Pizza restaurants

Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta

4.1 469 reviews Closed 23 Spring St, Schuylerville, NY 12871, United States

Discover this place

Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta, located in the charming village of Schuylerville, NY, has earned rave reviews from its patrons, proudly showcasing its exceptional offerings and dedicated service. Visitors like Jeff Gabriel highlight the "absolutely amazing food" and commend the friendly staff, especially during the popular Tuesday pizza special, which garners a perfect 10/10 recommendation. Keith Shaffer's experience speaks volumes about their commitment to customer satisfaction, as they willingly stayed open later to serve his group, proving they prioritize their guests.

The menu is a fan favorite, with Eli King Conklin frequently opting for the delectable Schuyler pizza, appreciating the personalized touch of having bleu cheese included each time. This attention to detail is echoed by Helen Stiassney’s review, where even a late order for hot wings and a large sausage mushroom pizza was met with kindness and professionalism, further illustrating the warm atmosphere.

Chelsea Eagan encapsulates the essence of this quaint eatery with her praise for its "wonderful customer service" and "fabulous food." Overall, Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta stands out not just for its delicious meals, but also for its outstanding commitment to creating memorable dining experiences in a cozy community hub.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta before visiting.

Reviews for Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta

4.1

469 reviews

100%

39%

12%

18%

Review highlights

Based on 469 reviews

Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta is consistently praised for its delicious food and friendly, attentive service. Customers frequently highlight the quality of the pizza, particularly specialty options like the Schuyler pizza, and appreciate the accommodating nature of the staff, who often go out of their way to ensure a positive dining experience—even during busy periods or near closing time. The restaurant's small-town charm and welcoming atmosphere contribute to its appeal, making it a favored local spot. While menu items generally meet high expectations, occasional minor feedback includes specific toppings preferences. Overall, Schuylerville Pizza & Pasta stands out for its combination of great food, reliable service, and a community-oriented vibe, encouraging repeat visits and strong recommendations from patrons.

Jeff Gabriel

Jun 21, 2025

Absolutely amazing food and the front end staff is awesome. Go there every Tuesday for the pizza special. 10/10 recommend to everyone.

Keith Shaffer

Jun 08, 2025

Called ahead due to closing soon, and they said that the group could still show up and eat. Stayed open later and had great service and amazing food! Will definitely be a repeat customer.

Eli King Conklin

May 31, 2025

Delicious food - we regularly get the Schuyler pizza and they always remember to check for my side of bleu cheese to go with it...that's service! Food is delicious and staff is very friendly and works hard to get things out fast even when they're slammed. Love this place

Chelsea Eagan

May 14, 2025

A cute small town eatery with wonderful customer service! The food was fabulous! Great team of employees- highly recommend!

Helen Stiassney

May 05, 2025

We ordered a large sausage mushroom pizza and hot wings, excellent!! I unknowingly ordered it 10 minutes before they closed! They close at 8p but online it said 9. The young lady at the counter said that was fine and insisted it ok! My only complaint is sliced sausage!

Erin Nudi

May 02, 2025

Came here for pickup which was super quick and the guy working there gave my son chocolate milk. I had a negative experience at a different establishment in the same day with my children - it really means so much to see friendly people who even just smile at and acknowledge my kids. And of course we enjoyed the great food!!

crazyamericandude USA

Apr 18, 2025

ordered a large calzone and it was the size of a 55 pound beagle hound HUGE calzone and delishhh

Amy Farrigan

Mar 29, 2025

We sat down and found out they were closing in a few minutes. The super nice woman who greeted and waited on us insisted it was okay. We are so happy we stayed. Best italian food we've had in awhile. Food portions were huge! Prices were so reasonable. Half of what we would expect to pay. We will definitely be back. It's not close to our home but so worth the drive. THANK YOU for your hospitality and delicious food